BOOK LIST RATINGS

RATERS' COMMENTS


Graham Forsdyke (acting editor) -- (2003) -- ISMACS News Annual

Privately Published. London, England


------------------------------

"Good to see ISMACS didn't think it was worth producing a second one and stopped production altogether."

___________________

"For an annual produced by a group of people claiming to represent sewing machine collectors this 'book' is a joke. It is mostly boring smiling faces and hardly any sewing machines! No table of contents, no index. A couple of good articles but the rest is amateurish rubbish."

------------------------------

"I wouldn't recommend this as a primary resource for sewing machine information but as a general interest magazine."

-------------------------------

"Excellent, quality production on nice paper, very nice photos and drawings and a nice front cover picture. Makes for interesting reading."

--------------------------------

"Still has an amateur feel to it. No index. Poor cover format."

---------------------------------

"Some excellent articles and good information, but no table of contents or index. Nice as a one-off read magazine, but would not recommend as a reference book."

------------------------------

 


© Alan Quinn 2003 All Rights Reserved
This page may not be reproduced or distributed in part or in whole without the prior written permission of the copyright owner